Bieb’s neighbour told TMZ that law enforcement officers were called to the star's home, in Calabasas, California, three times in the early hours of Saturday (15 November).
According to the site, police first visited the house - where the Never Say Never singer was throwing a party for around 100 people - at around 1am, and left after warning those inside to keep the noise down.
Two hours later, they were back following further complaints - and then came out a third time, around 5.30am, in order to take a disturbance of the peace report from the sleepless neighbour.
It’s now up to the police to decide whether to send the report to the Los Angeles County district attorney's office for possible prosecution.
It's not the first time Biebs has been accused of being a noisy neighbour.